Island Wedding Cakes and Catering

Tropical Island Cake | Custom Cakes | Cake Flavors & Frostings | Cake Toppers & Knife Set
Cup Cakes & Strawberries | Hors d'Oeuvres Platters & Catering

Let our award winning island baker bake you up a delicious and beautiful wedding cake to help celebrate!
The wedding cake is a reflection of the couple’s style so pick from our suggestions or help us create one for you!

Tropical Island Cake:

Tropical Island Cake

	Cake flavors: chocolate, red velvet, vanilla chiffon, key lime, lemon, and coconut
	Frosting/Filling flavors: almond, chocolate, lime, mocha, rum, vanilla
	Filling flavors: guava curd, key lime curd, lemon curd, passion fruit curd
	Vanilla frosting may be tinted one color at no extra charge.
	Prices start at $70 for a one layered 6 inch (serves up to 6 persons)
	Price includes delivery to wedding location or restaurant reception.
	Decorated table at your wedding location with complete set up of plates, utensils, cake knife, and napkins: $35 for decorative table and cake service for bride and groom. Add $5 per guest for cake service
	Restaurants typically will have a $6 per person plating service.

Tropical Island Cake Pricing:

One Tiered Round:

6 inch	serves up to 6	$70
8 inch	serves 7 to 9	$90
10 inch	serves 10 to 13	$120
12 inch	serves 14 to 17	$155

Two Tiered Round:

6 & 4 inch	serves up to 12	$140
8 & 6 inch	serves 13 to 20	$200
10 & 6 inch	serves 21 to 28	$270
10 & 8 inch	serves 29 to 35	$320
12 & 8 inch	serves 36 to 45	$405

Three Tiered - Four Tiered - and Sheet:

10, 8 & 6 inch	serves 31 to 40	$380
12, 10 & 8 inch	serves 60 to 70	$605
12, 10, 8, & 6 inch	serves 70 to 80	$665
8 x 12 sheet	serves up to 20	$110
12 x 16 sheet	serves 40-45	$165

To Top

Custom Cakes

Our award winning baker makes delicious and beautiful unforgettable cakes. Browse our selection for ideas or send in a photo of yours and we will get you a quote.

More photos of custom cakes

To Top

Cake flavors, fillings and frosting:

Cake Flavors:

Vanilla Chiffon

Chocolate Blackout

Red Velvet

Key Lime

Lemon

Coconut

Banana*

Carrot*

Cruzan Rum*

Hazelnut*

	Mojito; vanilla cake with flavors of that classic mint & rum drink from the ”Pirate” days of old*
	Caribbean Black Cake; an Island classic, dark fruitcake with Cruzan rum & cherry brandy*
	Vienna Cake-Caribbean Style; vanilla cake layered with homemade mango, guava & pineapple jams*

Fillings:

Guava Curd
Key Lime Curd
Lemon Curd
Passion Fruit Curd

Bavarian Cream*
Chocolate Truffle*
Coconut Cream*
Coffee Crème Brûlée*
Bavarian cream*

Cream Cheese*

Dulce de Leche*

Mango Compote*

Pina Colada*

Raspberry Compote*

Italian Buttercream for Frosting or Fillings:

Almond
Chocolate
Lime
Mocha
Rum

Coverings:
Chocolate Ganache*
White & Ivory Rolled Fondant*

Vanilla

Hazelnut Praline*

Peanut Butter*

White Chocolate*

*Denotes Premium Flavors/Surcharge Applies

To Top

Cake Toppers and Cake Knife Set
(cake toppers on cakes at least 7 inches in diameter)

Seashell Cake

Couple in the sand cake topper
Available in brown, black and white

Made of hand painted resin, this beach couple figurine measures 7" tall.
The groom lovingly carries his bride in the sand,which has been decorated with a heart and the words "Just Married."
A bit of ocean blue and a scattering of seashells also decorate the base

$35

Seashell Cake Topper

This resin seashell cake topper makes the perfect decoration
for a beach-themed wedding.
The two starfish are a perfect
beach-themed representation
of the bride and groom.

$30

Seashell Cake
Knife & Serving Set
This set includes one 12" long cake knife and one 9.5" long cake server.
Both are made of stainless steel.
The handle is made of cream acrylic. Each is accented by seashell and bead decorations.

$28

To Top

Cupcakes & Strawberries

Cupcakes made from scratch by our award-winning pastry chef
Choose vanilla, chocolate, coconut, or red velvet cake.
Vanilla or chocolate frosting. Vanilla frosting may be tinted at no extra charge.

Cupcakes delivered to your wedding or reception.
$6 per cupcake / $25 delivery / minimum 2 cupcakes
Add $2.50 per shell for sugar seashell topper on cupcake; choose white or tinted.
$40 for set up of decorative table, plates, utensils, and napkins. ($30 set up if combined with champagne or sand ceremony set up)

Chocolate Covered Strawberries:
$60 for first dozen.
Add $5 for each additional strawberry.
$6 for tuxedo strawberry. $6 for wedding dress strawberry.
$40 for set up of decorative table and napkins. ($20 set up if combined with champagne or sand ceremony set up)

To Top

Hors d'oeuvres Platters & Catering

Cheese, Fruit, and Veggie Platters

Tasty platters with a variety of cheeses, crackers, fruits, humus, veggies & ranch. Delivered to your wedding with plates, utensils, napkins, & tablecloth. $95/couple plus $15 per person

Add:
Assorted meats (variety ham, turkey, salami, roast beef - as available)- add $20/couple plus $10 per person
Medium Shrimp Cocktail - add $25/couple plus $12 per person ( 5 medium shrimp per person )
Large Shrimp Cocktail - add $30/couple plus $14 per person ( 5 large Shrimp per person)

* let us know if you don't want any item and we will give you extra of something else.

Ask us about catering everything from hot lunch buffets on the beach to sit down dinners at your villa!
Also check out our Beach Bums Picnics!

To Top

Hors d'oeuvres on the Beach - groups of 15 or more

	Provide your guests with some tasty Hors d'oeuvres on the beach after your wedding
	Select 3 hot and 2 cold:
	Hot Appetizers: Coconut Shrimp with dipping sauce Mushroom Caps stuffed with Pesto, Red Peppers, and Pinenuts, & topped with melted Mozzarella Cheese Large fresh Scallops wrapped in Hickory-Smoked Bacon Marinated Chicken Bites skewered with Pineapple and Grapes, served with a Sweet & Sour Dipping Sauce Extra Crispy Jalapeno Peppers stuffed with Cream Cheese with a Salsa side Chicken Drummettes slowly cooked with a Honey BBQ Dressing Meatballs with a Sweet & Sour Sauce Shisk Kabobs - Mix of veggies, Chicken & Shrimp Cold Appetizers: Chilled Shrimp served over a bed of Lettuce with Lemons & Cocktail Sauce Double-Cheese Bruschetta with Cherry Tomatoes & Kalamato Olives Assorted Crudites with a creamy Ranch-style Dip Asparagus wrapped with Prosciutto Imported & Domestic Cheese Display: Jalsberg, Smoked Gouda, Cheddar, Blue, Swiss, Havarti, assorted crackers & flatbreads Salmon Crostini with Cream Cheese, Red Onion, Peppers, Dill, & Lox Bruschetta of Roma Tomato and Fresh Basil and olive oil Asparagus Tips wrapped in Atlantic Smoked Salmon Homemade Crab "Salad" with a spicy Cocktail Sauce served over Cucumber rounds Tropical Fresh Fruit Includes Beverages: Fruit Punch Rum Punch Sodas Water
	We are currently working on rates for this - just ask!
	Ask us about adding beers-wines-champagne and other beverages
	Let us know if you have other food preferences and we will see what we can do.

Check out more Catering options at Beach Picnics & Receptions

Thanks for making our wedding renewal PERFECT at Magens Bay! It was a magical day with seamless effort on our part! You and your staff went above and beyond! Summer your correspondences were so timely, I felt at ease from the beginning. We are still in awe, that Malachi, our photographer, made reservations for us to eat, then escorted us to the restaurant so we didn't get lost! Minister Sprehn did an amazing job officiating the ceremony, keeping God at the center of our marriage! They included our boys and made them feel very special! A day we will always remember and thank God for each of you for making it possible!

In God's love,
The Gray's from Maryland with our hearts still in Magens Bay!
July 2014
Megans Bay